1546
Kick tankies out of 196 (lemmy.blahaj.zone)

Remember kids, Tankies wants to undermine democracy - same as facists.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] ichmagrum@feddit.de 8 points 11 months ago

Bit of a no true scotsman discussion.

[-] DessertStorms@kbin.social 8 points 11 months ago* (last edited 11 months ago)

Only if you're the kind who would argue that Hitler was a socialist, or that the CCP is communist.

Communism and socialism aren't vague nebulous concepts, they are very well defined, and those definitions are, as stated above, inherently incompatible with tankies' actions (or at least the actions they support and stand for), never mind that co-opting leftist language and ideas is a well known and documented tactic the right use to manipulate people in to supporting them, before they drop the mask to reveal their true authoritarian bigoted selves (ETA: even if a dictator started out meaning well, once they become a dictator, they've abandoned communism).

But sure, name an unrelated fallacy instead of thinking for yourself, that's sure to end well.. 🙄

Don't feel too bad, at least you got to feel like you "got me" there for a millisecond!

(pasting this edit here too, to be clear: trying to achieve communism, and actually doing it are very different things, and if you end up with an authoritarian regime, you've not achieved communism, no matter what you call it, it really isn't complicated)

[-] CancerMancer@sh.itjust.works 7 points 11 months ago

How so? Communism ultimately describes a society where power is spread amongst the people, while authoritarianism describes a system where power is concentrated at the top. What could possibly be communist about an authoritarian regime?

[-] mycorrhiza@lemmy.ml 7 points 11 months ago

Look at Indonesia in 1965–66 to see what happens to peaceful communists. Or Chile in 73. They’re rounded up and slaughtered by US-backed fascists. The reason ML theory prescribes a period of authoritarianism is to defend against this.

[-] Meowoem@sh.itjust.works 2 points 11 months ago

But power being spread among the people doesn't mean there's no rules or organisation, just because you work in a communist run flour mill doesn't mean you can piss in the flour.

So we get into structure issues, we can all vote on if pissing in the flour should be allowed and what the punishment should be for doing it - this is the difference between communism and anarchy, literally living without a ruler Vs living in commune under shared values.

We dont all want to spend all day voting on what we can piss on so we could theoretically vote for a representative we like to do that for us - if all the local villages did that the representatives could all get together and debate and vote somewhere but to stop everyone talking over each other you'd want a secretary so they could vote for one and if the secretaries all got together for a regional or national meeting they would want a secretary too...

It would be natural to expect these people to act in the best interest of the people without ruining and asking everyone to vote on every little thing but of course they're not going to be acting in the best interests of the flour pissers - from the flour pissers perspective if the top secretary passes a bill to say no flour pissing then they're a big bad authoritarian.

(And don't confuse dictator with authoritarian, they're not synonyms)

[-] ichmagrum@feddit.de 1 points 11 months ago

That's entirely secondary to whether people get called communists. If everyone calls them communists, including themselves, it's ultimately futile to try to call them anything else.

[-] Leviathan@lemmy.world 4 points 11 months ago

North Korea calls itself democratic, does that make it so? No.

[-] rockSlayer@lemmy.world 7 points 11 months ago

I too believe that anarcho-monarchism is valid and not at all contradictory

this post was submitted on 23 Oct 2023
1546 points (99.8% liked)

196

16251 readers
2317 users here now

Be sure to follow the rule before you head out.

Rule: You must post before you leave.

^other^ ^rules^

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS