this post was submitted on 12 Apr 2024
102 points (93.2% liked)
Religious Cringe
844 readers
1 users here now
About
This is the official Lemmy for the r/ReligiousCringe***** subreddit. This is a community about poking fun at the religious fundamentalist's who take their religion a little bit too far. Here you will find religious content that is so outrageous and so cringeworthy that even someone who is mildly religious will cringe.
Rules
-
All posts must contain religious cringe. All posts must be made from a religious person or must be showcasing some kind of religious bigotry. The only exception to this is rule 2
-
Material about religious bigots made by non-bigots is only allowed from Friday-Sunday EST. In an effort to keep this community on the topic of religious cringe and bigotry we have decide to limit stuff like atheist memes to only the weekends.
-
No direct links to religious cringe. To prevent religious bigots from getting our clicks and views directs links to religious cringe are not allowed. If you must a post a screenshot of the site or use archive.ph. If it is a YouTube video please use a YouTube frontend like Piped or Invidious
-
No Proselytizing. Proselytizing is defined as trying to convert someone to a particular religion or certain world view. Doing so will get you banned.
-
Spammers and Trolls will be instantly banned. No exceptions.
Resources
International Suicide Hotlines
Non Religious Organizations
Freedom From Religion Foundation
Ex-theist Communities
Other Similar Communities
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
You're changing the subject. While the OP is about christianity, this little subthread is about whether someone can lose their belief in atheism. Nobody in this subthread mentioned christianity until you did, and nobody in this subthread is a christian. I would appreciate some good faith engagement instead of changing the subject to those other guys over there we both hate. You hate em, I hate em, let's get over it and actually have a fruitful discussion.
You're saying you don't believe in a system of atheism. I'm taking this to mean you don't have any beliefs asserting your atheism. So if I accused you of not being an atheist, you wouldn't deny it, right? Cause you don't believe anything about you being an atheist. There are no beliefs you possess for me to challenge if I call you a theist, correct? You'd go along with it or hold a neutral view?
God damn, Lemmy's got some dumb fuckin' users.
While you accuse me of not following the logic of your argument, you didn't follow mine. I never said I was an atheist, you just assumed it. Actually, I'm agnostic. The reality is I don't give a shit if you think I'm an atheist or not. Calling an atheist a theist is inaccurate, so is calling me one, but it doesn't personally offend me, it's just an inaccurate statement because it assigns a belief that I don't hold.
Maybe respond in good faith if you want good faith back
Atheism, by definition, is an absence of belief in deities. If you "accused" an atheist of "not being an atheist," they would think you were confused about what atheism is. They would likely not be personally offended by your ignorance.
I don't know why anyone would "go along with it" were you to incorrectly assert they held beliefs which they did not, but if they did, it would likely be in pity for or exasperation with the person impotently trying to "gotcha" their "beliefs."
So, you're playing a trick here. You're saying you don't have any beliefs, but you're also saying you think I'm wrong. That's not an absence of belief. That's a negative belief. Belief in the absence of something, not absence of beliefs. You're mixing the two up.
Here, I'll explain with a hypothetical. Imagine you're on a space ship with someone who doesn't believe in vacuums. They think there's air everywhere. They say the air in the ship is stuffy, and they want to open the window to get some fresh air in. You tell them that you're all going to die if you do that, because there's no air. It's not that you have no beliefs, it's that you specifically believe there is no air. It's a belief in absence, not an absence of belief. Your belief in there being no air informs all sorts of other beliefs, like the belief that opening the window will kill you.
Do you have a belief in the absence of theism regarding yourself, or do you have an absence of belief regarding your religious status? You can only pick one, they're mutually exclusive. You cannot have both.
Unfortunately for your ego, you have nothing relevant or novel to "explain" to me; you did not arrive at this discussion with an adequate understanding of "belief" or "atheism."
And to your further misfortune, you haven't developed the necessary reverence for growth which typically fosters the humility to recognize one's own ignorance and error.
But the most salient bad luck you've wrought here has been the pain and loss of those who have chosen to read and engage with your blithering comments made in bad faith.
My ego? I don't have much of an ego, I'm just a regular drone. If you think I'm important though thanks
They believe the absence of theism; the deity or religion is not relevant. It's really that simple.