I don't think the feature should be removed. Perhaps it can be reworked or improved for selecting text, but I personally appreciate the click to collapse. Very convenient to skip forward to the next item.
this post was submitted on 17 Jul 2023
53 points (72.3% liked)
Jerboa
10299 readers
1 users here now
Jerboa is a native-android client for Lemmy, built using the native android framework, Jetpack Compose.
Warning: You can submit issues, but between Lemmy and lemmy-ui, I probably won't have too much time to work on them. Learn jetpack compose like I did if you want to help make this app better.
Built With
Features
- Open source, AGPL License.
Installation / Releases
Support / Donate
Jerboa is made by Lemmy's developers, and is free, open-source software, meaning no advertising, monetizing, or venture capital, ever. Your donations directly support full-time development of the project.
Crypto
- bitcoin:
1Hefs7miXS5ff5Ck5xvmjKjXf5242KzRtK - ethereum:
0x400c96c96acbC6E7B3B43B1dc1BB446540a88A01 - monero:
41taVyY6e1xApqKyMVDRVxJ76sPkfZhALLTjRvVKpaAh2pBd4wv9RgYj1tSPrx8wc6iE1uWUfjtQdTmTy2FGMeChGVKPQuV - cardano:
addr1q858t89l2ym6xmrugjs0af9cslfwvnvsh2xxp6x4dcez7pf5tushkp4wl7zxfhm2djp6gq60dk4cmc7seaza5p3slx0sakjutm
Contact
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
I agree it's great but I would love if it were moved to a separate button along with a button at the top of a post to collapse all comments so you can skim through top-level comments more easily.
One issue I keep encountering with this click to hide implementation is that users post a thumbnail sized image and when I try to click on it to see full size, wind up just hiding the comment.
RiF had the option of collapse all childs, but I think it was a setting that applied everywhere, not a functionality you could use in a thread by thread basis.
I also like collapsing comments, but I don't like that clicking almost anywhere on the comment it collapsed it. Sometimes even trying to upvote a comment it keep collapsing it.
And if you click on collapsed comment it sometimes takes you to commenter's profile instead of expanding the comment.
A button with +/- symbols would be nice.
How about an option to switch the functionality? "Long press to: option A, option B, etc"
I'm a fan of this; it's how Slide handled it.
I also prefer Slide's method of collapsing comments; it only collapses the child comments, not the one you pressed on. (although it also has an option to collapse it too)
The "show content for collapsed comments" option does what I think you want. It'll cause tapping on a comment to hide it's children but otherwise leave that comment visible.
That it does, thank you! The highlighted +X indicator is appreciated as well.
The problem isn't comments collapsing. it's links being too hard to click
Right? What is even the point of the hiding upvotes option? I can understand holding to show upvotes if you have them hidden by default, but why would anyone ever want to hide upvotes on an individual basis? It's a wasted gesture.
This is my fault, I did that. The honest answer: it was really easy to implement and now the app does by default what I prefer, I hide the comment action bar of course. In the future I want to add options to control gestures on comments, just haven't gotten around to it yet.
Disagree. I like it this way and have no problem with links.
I don't always have problems with comments with links, but it happens sometimes, specially if the link is small.
In Boost I found it nice to hold to collapse, that way it wouldn't erroneously do it if you just mis-tapped something. Copying text could be done through a separate menu.
I prefer hold for selecting text, but collapsing it's a better alternative that the current functionality of hiding the upvote buttons, that is pretty useless imo (can't even think of a user case for that)
I like the comment collapse feature. It's nice to be able to quickly collapse a long comment group. I've clicked on links before without a problem.
Long press would be good for selecting text though.
I also like collapsing comments, my problem is with the way is implemented, sometimes even trying to upvote something collapse the comment.
Out of all the apps I tried on Android, only Connect has a special button to collapse comments. All the others work like Jerboa.
Iirc, RiF had a button where the profile pic is here.
Yeah. Connect is like that, though the button is in a slightly different place. Could be put right after the user name or something. Just a little [-].
Usernames have pretty different length, putting the button after it would make the position of it inconsistent and potentially even dissappear is the username is long. Before the userpic is a better option imo.
Also to uncollapse them you have to tap the comment from the right side, otherwise youll go to their profile page. Perhaps the user link could be deactivated if the comment is collapsed.
It'd be nice if the app remembered which comments I collapsed. It's quite annoying having all the comments expand back after I write a reply.
Should be there in the next update for most cases, including replies.
RiF had a specific collapse button. It should be similar in Jerboa
Most Reddit apps I used worked like this by default. It's not my preference either (I liked Slide because I could swap the tap and long-press actions) but I'm not complaining.
I remember when this was a requested feature... Apparently it's how it works in some reddit app
view more: next ›