I have Evasion, so uhhh... Yup, zero damage.
this post was submitted on 04 Nov 2023
242 points (96.2% liked)
RPGMemes
10341 readers
427 users here now
Humor, jokes, memes about TTRPGs
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
DC 20 isn't even hard considering the effect it's supposed to have.
Level 7 rogue that just got Evasion has a +3 proficiency and could have 20 dex, so succeeds for ZERO damage on a 12, and never takes full.
I think the scroll should've split between Force and Fire damage. Make the Force damage a CON save for half, because you can't avoid it, only tank it, and make the fire the dex save.
Then rogues still get to use Evasion, but it's not "I anime dodge the comet".
Eh. If the wizard can conjure it, the rogue should be able to dodge it.
I know it makes my GM twitch whenever my rogue or monk would dodge an explosion. But we have to disillusion ourselves of the ridiculous notion that martial characters have to obey the laws of physics.
But we have to disillusion ourselves of the ridiculous notion that martial characters have to obey the laws of physics.
With the amount of damage that martial characters can tank or dish out, I think the only explanation is that martials use magic as well, just not the conscious brainy kind. There must be some subconscious muscle magic going on that bends reality in a more subtle and localised way.
No topic has ever gotten me into more D&D arguments than saying that a 10th level fighter should be able to fall off an airship, hit the ground and not immediately splat, but rather limp away from it after tanking the 20d6 damage.
I want a squad of Dwarven Fighters to be able to leap off of the same airship and do a three-point landing, because what the hell would Dwarves need parachutes for?!
SUPERHERO LANDING!
It's so hard on the knees....
Its actually half damage if you pass. Half of 30d10.
Evasion reduces dex save effects to half damage on a failure, and no damage on a success. The rogue and the monk can dodge the comet completely.
As can the Wizard if they have a Pseudodragon familiar. At least in 3.0/3.5 it worked that way.
load more comments
(1 replies)
Bear totem barbarian. Half of half
Hide in a fridge.
Using the asteroid impact calculator at https://apps.science.purdue.edu/eaps/crater/cgi/crater_c.cgi, a crater of this size is equal to approximately 7 kilotonnes, which is light tactical nuclear weapon level. Large enough to vaporise city blocks, refrigerators, and any rogues evading into said refrigerators
oh but it doesn't work if you're inside apparently
You have to see the ~~sky~~ comet to manipulate the comet, isn't that right? You can't just have wizards willy-nilly affecting matter that they can't perceive!
And don't even think about using windows! The devil's doorways, they are
Makes sense. Who's gonna guide the comet down, imaginary sky friends?
You can't dodge all the damage with most builds, but the damage is actually spread out over a short duration and you can use the i-frames in dodge to negate some of it.
Fast rolling helps.
It clearly states you still take damage if you pass, an almost certainly fatal amount. Basically your character hides in a fridge or something like Indiana Jones.
Improved Evasion. You take no damage if successful, and 50% on a failed DEX check. Utterly broken, especially when the Wizard realizes that their pseudodragon familiar is why they can suddenly dodge better than the rogue, though I think the pseudodragon was actually casting dimension door or something.
Hol'up. What's this meta?
That's how it worked in 3.0/3.5, not sure if that holds true in 5th e.
Ah, the golden era 🤘🏼🌈
https://youtu.be/OoVV1WThyZ8?si=LT84Gqg9RBAK5m7n just parry it!
This is the only thing I know about this game and I cannot wait for it to come out
hey, if you're not bothered by 15d10 dmg, i am impressed
That's only like 82.5 damage, I'm fine
Nah, that blood was there before I coughed
Is it a real speed comet or an anime speed comet ?
15d10 damage on a successful save is still an average of 82.5 damage, or enough to kill a peasant 20.5 times over. I presume the Dex save is being able to find a relatively safe crevasse or something—the key word being "relative", since they'll still take enough damage to kill a rhino twice.
Using commoners to see how damaging a spell is is like using a cat to test out an anti-vehicle mine designed to explode on any contact and weight.
What is a comet that can only deal up to 300 damage. Laughable.
Honestly, a pretty good answer is that if the lower damage bound is 30, the "comet" just isn't that big really.
Lower bound is actually 15 on successful saving throw.
I've never seen a PC with more than 200hp
Anime dodge and hang in the air for 35 seconds. Ez
I-frames obviously
Just have to dodge roll at the right time. Easy.
Don't forget that rogues get that perk (level 10 I think?) where they always get half damage whenever it calls for a DEX save and zero damage if they succeed
It's like jumping out of a car at highway speeds vs. jumping out of a car at highway speeds, tucking, and rolling. Either way, you'll be seriously hurt or killed, but one way is a little more likely to seriously hurt you and a little less likely to kill you than the other.
Also it's a world where one bardy boi singing real good has significant real life effects.
Why shouldn't someone be so good at dodging that they can evade half of the damage an explosion does?
Duh. You jump into the air and ride the air currents to safety. Everyone knows comets crashing creates waves of wind due to the displacement.
Probably to hide under a desk... I wonder if bringing your own gives you advantage on the roll?
This is leaving out that a mile away from an impact that creates a 50-foot crater is in no way safe. Anyone know someone who could do the math on this?
Did it in a top level comment. Not sure how to link to it in an instance-independent manner
That calculator is going to provide me with hours of ghoulish fun, thanks!