I am very much in favor of this.

I have a small collection of short horror I have been working on, on my personal website, and it turns out there is no subreddit on reddit that you can share your own horror stories on.

Before you suggest it, /r/NoSleep had extremely specific requirements for the formats of stories you post, you couldnt just post any ole horror story to there.

Aside from that there were a couple small places you could share writing in general for review, but that was much more focused on actual writing critiques and not just general sharing of stuff.

Would be nice to see a general scary story hive where we can post and read stuff folks have read

Get into short horror stories. GOOD stories published by professional magazines like Nightmare, The Dark, Black Static, Weird Horror, Pseudopod. Those are all places that pay professional rates and who have won tons of awards. Anthologies edited by Ellen Datlow are also good, who does the Year’s Best. Crystal Lake Publishing is good as well, both their short stories, novels, and their podcasts. Weird Little Worlds is another indie publisher that has put out good stuff. (Disclosure: I’ve had stories published by both CLP and WLW—the Mother: Tales of Love and Terror antho I was in was a finalist for the Bram Stoker award this year.)

If you want good horror, you need to go to the places that publish it professionally. Issues are pretty cheap, and there’s plenty of free stuff on their sites as well.