We know they hearded them off cliffs in many parts of the world, probably egged on by throwing spears and jabs.
It seems pretty unlikely they'd have regularly risked death by planting a spear and waiting for a charge. It's not like a multiple ton animal is going to be stopped by the spear.
Also it’s unlikely people across the world all used the same hunting method.
Goading or herding a mammoth into a pre-planted pikewall seems much more likely than a single hunter planting a spear and waiting for a charge.
Narrow or raised terrain, hunting blinds or other kinds of prepared cover could also make a more in the moment sort of plant-and-dodge tactic less likely to result in injury.
Just hiding those pikes in some shrubbery would do the trick.
A nice one. Next to this one here. Now GO! Or we shall say Ni to you a second time!
I'm not an archeologist in any way, but yeah what you said makes way more sense than what the article describes. It would be nearly suicide to wait for a big animal to charge at you and then try to pike them with a spear. There are so many safer and equally efficient ways to use a spear to kill an animal.
Just off the top of my head i can imagine lots of ways to do it. Like use 10 foot spears and herd the animal into a trench, then a bunch of guys can safely stab it from above. Or herd it into an enclosed area and then drop a bunch of heavy logs into the exit so the animal is trapped, then throw spears at it from a safe area. Etc
You would need a lot of time and energy to build a trench, mammoths may not stay in the area.
I am under the impression you don't stay with the spear and its spike zone serving a similar purpose as a trench. Maybe they realized mammoths will try to ram those if you provoke em from behind the spikes zone.
Especially in a snowy area i can see it doable to quickly plant some spikes walls in the snow to help wall in an animal. Though it may be just bias that i assume mammoth = snow area
Doesn’t exclude using other techniques combined with that. I am pretty sure that trenches with spikes did exist some time in history
That makes sense honestly. I can’t imagine developing enough power even with an atlatl to sink a javelin deep enough to kill a mammoth.
That was always my thought when looking at those points: "How exactly did a person throw that through the skin of an elephant?"
A modern paleo-hunting enthusiast showed that an atlatl can generate enough power to one-shot a bison. The projectile pierced the opposite side, I believe.
Obviously a planted pike is going to be more force, but I wouldn't be surprised if atlatl mammoth kills are possible.
Sheer balls of steel letting that massive beast charge right at you while holding a spear and bracing for impact.
Isn't this what the guy did on accident in the movie 10,000 B.C.
humans may have braced the butt
He he he
He he he... >!braced!<
how are you tricking an animal into charging straight into a tree or something?
Probably taunt it into running at you
Yo mama was a mastodon!
Or you could taunt it a second time.
but they can see the tree behind you.
Tree?
scroll up?
Into a tree? What are you talking about?
I'm guessing you can do the old trick of lying them flat and then jerking them up at the perfect moment with rope. Or as the article says, have balls of steel and let the animal charge you, planting the spear at the very last moment
maybe it was a pike wall like in combat
I think what they are getting at is that an animal tends to not want to run into a spear, so I'm thinking there might be some trickery involved such as concealing the spear or rapidly bringing it to bear
Waiting for my new Far Cry Primal update now.
This makes way more sense and it's way more epic. Well played, ancestors.
Notice Board
This is a work in progress, please don't mind the mess.
About
Archaeology or archeology[a] is the study of human activity through the recovery and analysis of material culture. The archaeological record consists of artifacts, architecture, biofacts or ecofacts, sites, and cultural landscapes.
Archaeology has various goals, which range from understanding culture history to reconstructing past lifeways to documenting and explaining changes in human societies through time.
The discipline involves surveying, excavation, and eventually analysis of data collected, to learn more about the past. In broad scope, archaeology relies on cross-disciplinary research. Read more...
Rules
Links
Archaeology 101:
Get Involved:
University and Field Work:
Jobs and Career:
Professional Organisations:
FOSS Tools:
Datasets:
Fun:
Other Resources:
Find us on Reddit
