23
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 08 Sep 2024
23 points (100.0% liked)
Comradeship // Freechat
2157 readers
9 users here now
Talk about whatever, respecting the rules established by Lemmygrad. Failing to comply with the rules will grant you a few warnings, insisting on breaking them will grant you a beautiful shiny banwall.
A community for comrades to chat and talk about whatever doesn't fit other communities
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
I think it's really unfair to describe fears over the Taliban as being fearmongering. Maybe exaggerated, but not without merit.
I also think it's really unfair to the general population of Afghanistan to describe the Taliban as the "rightful" government, given the decades the people suffered under the bootheel of American imperialism and now the far-right theocratic nutjobs of the Taliban that view women as objects.
I feel disgusting even saying these words, but I can tolerate Russia working with the Taliban, since the Taliban are at least trying their hand at operating a state, and can't govern the country as a complete dictatorship without risking being overthrown/kicked out by the Afghan people or being overthrown by an Amerikkkan-aligned invasion.
I think it's perfectly fair to describe western publications' fearmongering about the Taliban as what it is, though. Criticism of the Taliban is more than warranted- but when it's coming from the same countries that were celebrating the mujaheddin (even in their movies) only a few decades prior and flying Islamic extremists in from all over the globe- when it's coming from the countries which then afterwards militarily occupied Afghanistan for 2 decades while having tribal warlords/cartels as their collaborator-regime and which continues to destabilize the country through the bloody ISIS (ISIS-K)...
Yeah, western state, mainstream media, and NGO (granted, may as well have said "western state" 3x) crocodile tears about the Taliban are fearmongering. The Taliban is what the west inflicted on Afghanistan, and then everything they have inflicted since has managed to somehow be worse. Criticism of the Taliban from leftists and the global south is valid, but western media doesn't have a leg to stand on, actually it's worse than that, the west offers Afghanistan nothing but terrorism, dictatorships, and destruction, and they're to blame for everything wrong with the Taliban and then some.
All very fair points, and I wasn't trying to say that the Taliban aren't the fault of the west, I was speaking from the perspective of if I lived in Afghanistan.
Fears of them doing what exactly?
Let's see, if we talk about influence on ordinary Americans... stopping the supply for much of CIA fueled opioid epidemic in USA?
I just meant if I was a person living under the Taliban government
your quotation is wrong. I said "legitimate", not rightful.
"Legitimate", as in they're the dominant governing body within the country and have been accepted by nearly every country as the genuine government of Afghanistan.
And it is fear-mongering. I was in kindergarten when 9/11 happened, I grew up seeing the US villainize Islam and Arabs in real time. In my youth, we were told that the Taliban were the greatest evil to ever walk the planet. There is a lot to criticise about the Taliban, they're not leftist and their interpretation of Islam is heretical. But they're not the human embodiment of the devil Americans so desperately want to believe they are.
In the instance of this headline, western news publications want people to think "Taliban = hate", then think "if Putin works with the Taliban, that means he endorses them". Thus stoking anti-Russia sentiments by using the decades of anti-Muslim fear-mongering they've been giving us since the 1990s.
I am aware that you said legitimate and not rightful. It still has a bad taste in my mouth.
Yeah, I grew up during the post 9/11 hysteria too. Shit was dark.
I agree with your point about Amerikkkans linking Taliban and Putin as a shortcut to mean "evil" brown people.
https://amu.tv/30372/
Taliban governors from 6 provinces already have schools open for girls. They just need to develop the facilities, they'd probably have already done so nationwide if the US didn't bomb them for 20 years.
https://genevasolutions.news/explorations/dispatches-from-women-in-afghanistan/girls-return-to-high-school-in-some-regions-of-afghanistan
This is eye-opening, thank you.