14
What are some actual critiques of the Shining Path?
(lemmygrad.ml)
Prolewiki is editing a whole book coming out soon on this topic, stay tuned 😉
Love yall! keep up the good work!
I spoke to many Peruvians regarding the Miraflores massacre and it did not sound like bourgeois propaganda (as Maoists like to claim) to me.
I identified as a Maoist as the time. The people I spoke to were usually sympathetic to leftism.
My tour guide who has lived in the area his entire life identified as a "social nationalist" (not a "national socialist", a socialist and Peruvian nationalist) and he said he respected me for my revolutionary anti-imperialist worldview. He called the Shining Path cowards, fools, terrorists, and hypocrites, claiming they stand for indigenous rights while constantly using them as human shields.
I am aware that one person's "terrorist" is another person's freedom fighter. The PCP is hated by almost everyone in Peru. Peasants. Other communists. Many indigenous groups. Their idea of "revolutionary violence" included murdering leftists, unionists, and indigenous rights activists that they disagree with.
May Gonzalo burn in hell. He was no revolutionary. He was a petit-bourgeois cult leader willing to send anyone and everyone to their fucking death while he was kicking back and writing "theory" that included little more than narcissistic ramblings about his own brilliance.
I spit on the "Fourth Sword of Communism". As for the rest of the guerillas in the party, I am sure many are well-intentioned and there is no denying that Peru is controlled by little more than a fascist led U.S.-comprador state that deserves all the violence it can get.
Not peasants. Not the indigenous. Not other communists. Not random fucking people in the middle of Lima.
Whatever you have claimed here is anecdotal rubbish and has no value to any serious researcher. Revolution is not a dinner party and making humanist allegations is the last thing a so called communist should do. If you ever bothered to research the trial of Gonzalo you would know that there was no not a single shred of evidence of the PCP being responsible for the Tarata Bombing.
Here's the one I have: the shining path discredited the idea of a revolutionary socialist movement in a society that desperately needs one. The thing about the shining path manifesto is it reads like a parody of what a Imperialist shill thinks communism is. And after Gonzalo was out of the picture the movement declined repidly(Don't get me wrong, Fujimori and his ilk are among the worst murderous neoliberal sellout ghouls imaginable.) Revolutionary movements should be last because they are supported by the masses not because their cult leader was captured. A good example of a revolutionary movement gone correctly for example os Bolivia right next door and MAS. When Evo got taken out of the picture by the coup the movement survived because it was built among the masses and they were able to struggle against the neoliberal regime and win their freedom.
I'd recommend BadEmpenada's video on the shining path for more details he goes into far more detail than I can here.
Its why I don't consider myself a MLM. I can't. Though I'd follow along Mao Zedong thought once I've read up on his works though I don't know if its enough to turn me into a Maoist.
To be fair, haven't multiple communist movements been dismantled after their leaders were captured/killed? I agree a strong movement can fight back after regrouping, but I'm not sure its always true. Though this doesn't diminish Gonzalo's evil.
Usually the leaders capture is the symptom of the dismantling of a movement not it's direct cause. The shining path was utterly dependent on Gonzalo to function.
I found a YouTube link in your comment. Here are links to the same video on alternative frontends that protect your privacy:
If you are done with the Cherrypicking. I will let you know that Gonzalo was not the only leader captured. The entire central committee was arrested. This is a massive strategic setback for any organization.
Mandatory reminder that Shining Path has been deliverately targeting and committing massacres against LGBT+ peoples throughout its history - As late as 2021.
Also the MRTA doesn't get nearly enough shit for doing the same as well.
If you researched enough, you would know that the organization responsible for that attack is the MPCP not the PCP, as mentioned in your own shared article.
🤓
The MPCP is a group that splintered from the PCP taking most of its members with itself, and the only reason it exists as such is because they saw the PCP agreeing on a ceasefire with the Peruvian state after Gonzalo's capture as an act of treason from his part. On everything but in name, they are the PCP. Nonetheless, that still doesn't take away the fact that the PCP prior to its split had consistently committed massacres against LGBT peoples through most of its history.
Also, why are you reviving a dead thread?
The MPCP is a group that splintered from the PCP taking most of its members with itself,
It is evident that your only knowledge about the group is surface level Wikipedia reading because this is just a blatant lie you took word by word from Wikipedia. The MPCP consists of ex-PAF and that is also written in there if you bothered to read it carefully.
and the only reason it exists as such is because they saw the PCP agreeing on a ceasefire with the Peruvian state after Gonzalo's capture as an act of treason from his part.
The ceasefire was a fabrication by the Peruvian Fascist State. Guzman proved it in his call to arms while being displayed inside a cage to the media.
On everything but in name, they are the PCP.
This shows that you do not know anything about the PCP General Political Line or even its history. This is evident by you comparing a proletarian vanguard which waged a People's War and almost brought the Peruvian State to its knees to a Government Propped up Drug Trafficking Organization. I find it baffling as to what equation you are trying to draw here by just saying the opposite in the previous part. "They splintered off because they had a major disagreement, but they are the same party now because yeah." Is this not a false analogy and strawman of Maoists? No Maoist upholds the MPCP.
Nonetheless, that still doesn't take away the fact that the PCP prior to its split had consistently committed massacres against LGBT peoples through most of its history.
There is no evidence for this. While in fact, the PCP clearly said that they never targetted LGBTQ individuals/groups just because of their identity as such.
Also, why are you reviving a dead thread?
This shows your disinterest and unseriousness in Proletarian Politics and in developing an anti-revisionist knowledge of history. You are treating this as something like a game. Yes, it has been an inactive thread for 3 weeks but you are posting misinformation that will permanently be here. Sorry, but my conscience cannot let you do that.
This shows your disinterest and unseriousness
Yea.
You are treating this as something like a game.
The fate of the proletariat's liberation rests on the outcome of a thread on a reddit copycat.
Yea. Then I am not interested in furthering this discussion. Have a great day.
Have a nice day you too, dear random maoist.
here is something that may be useful- https://en.maoisme.no/2021/12/04/maoism-vs-mlmpm/
their documents are on my to read pile, its like a 1000 pages long from the start of the formation of the party till the present, so I cannot give an accurate critique as of now.
thank you!
That is a decent article. I disagree on a few points but I will look into them later. (If you read the PCP documents, you may come across the disagreements I am talking about.) I suggest reading the Nepali and Indian Maoist Comrades documents regarding this topic as well. There is no single piece talking specifically about this so you will have to read a bunch of papers to get some paragraphs talking about it. They are available on Bannedthought. (Use VPN/Tor if you reside in India, Philippines or China.)
If you are aware about the ICL (International Communist League), you can also read its statements and the criticisms regarding it. (Available on Bannedthought) The ICL is a primarily Gonzaloite "Communist International" and they have been criticized by the CPI(M) and the RCPN on many points which I suggest giving a read as well.
I suggest reading the documents published by the PCP first to get a proper overall idea instead of reading the criticisms first.
And I will assert here that a fair criticism must be made. The PCP certainly had many errors and these have been talked about by the Nepali Maoists and the CPI(M) however bad faith and logically fallacious slandering as done by a few individuals in this thread has a very negative effect.
Edit 1: I will edit and append links to documents which specifically talk about criticisms of the PCP if I come across them later.
this post was submitted on 10 Nov 2023
14 points (85.0% liked)
Communism
9453 readers
3 users here now
Discussion Community for fellow Marxist-Leninists and other Marxists.
Rules for /c/communism
Rules that visitors must follow to participate. May be used as reasons to report or ban.
- No non-marxists
This subreddit is here to facilitate discussion between marxists.
There are other communities aimed at helping along new communists. This community isn't here to convert naysayers to marxism.
If you are a member of the police, armed forces, or any other part of the repressive state apparatus of capitalist nations, you will be banned.
- No oppressive language
Do not attempt to justify your use of oppressive language.
Doing this will almost assuredly result in a ban. Accept the criticism in a principled manner, edit your post or comment accordingly, and move on, learning from your mistake.
We believe that speech, like everything else, has a class character, and that some speech can be oppressive. This is why speech that is patriarchal, white supremacist, cissupremacist, homophobic, ableist, or otherwise oppressive is banned.
TERF is not a slur.
- No low quality or off-topic posts
Posts that are low-effort or otherwise irrelevant will be removed.
This is not a place to engage in meta-drama or discuss random reactionaries on lemmy or anywhere else.
This includes memes and circlejerking.
This includes most images, such as random books or memorabilia you found.
We ask that amerikan posters refrain from posting about US bourgeois politics. The rest of the world really doesn’t care that much.
- No basic questions about marxism
Posts asking entry-level questions will be removed.
Questions like “What is Maoism?” or “Why do Stalinists believe what they do?” will be removed, as they are not the focus on this forum.
- No sectarianism
Marxists of all tendencies are welcome here.
Refrain from sectarianism, defined here as unprincipled criticism. Posts trash-talking a certain tendency or marxist figure will be removed. Circlejerking, throwing insults around, and other pettiness is unacceptable.
If criticisms must be made, make them in a principled manner, applying Marxist analysis.
The goal of this subreddit is the accretion of theory and knowledge and the promotion of quality discussion and criticism.
Check out ProleWiki for a communist wikipedia.
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS