Since Israel has spent 40 years making two states, one for each side impossible, the only solution now is a single state that guarantees equal rights for all citizens, and is dedicated to a truth and reconciliation process where the old injustices of both sides are resolved.

It would be named Palestine

All living Palestinians get to return to their homes, which are rebuilt as needed. Remaining unhoused Palestinians get new homes. The state of Israel and its backers pay ongoing reparations, and their leaders (military, political, and media) are tried for war crimes. Israeli citizens are re-educated. A new government is formed which gives Palestinians equal status, vigorously enforced. Whether that new government is a two state solution, one state replacement for Israel, or no state anarchist utopia is not as important as the rest, and is much more contingent on who's enforcing the change with what power.

I don't necessarily agree with the stance that every Israeli must leave the country, but that stance is not inherently racist.

The state of Israel is a settler colony that has stolen land from it's native inhabitants, murdered and displaced those inhabitants, and forced them into apartheid. To believe that the people that have committed these atrocities should leave is an opinion not rooted in race.

A single, multi-ethnic and secular state.

1 state solution with equal rights for all, but transfer of all land, wealth, industries, companies, and bureaucratic positions to the Palestinians.

Abolish the education system, abolish the apartheid military, and have mandatory re-education and reparations payments from ex-settlers.

Sometimes I’ll see people saying that all Israelis should just move somewhere else, but I think that’s really dumb. Both sides seem to be operating on the assumption that the other group will leave, which in my opinion is just as racist thinking as saying all the Palestinians should just leave.

Yeah, when they, {the settlers} lose their economic and political privileges of apartheid and settler colonialism, I'm pretty sure a lot of them would just leave (see Algeria's Pied Noir, Zimbabwe and South Africa's white elites, Angola and Mozambique's retornados), though most of them to note are probably European or 'White' American descended (East or West European).

As for the remaining Jews, which are likely Sephardic and Middle Eastern (Mizrahi means 'Oriental'), let them be... they once lived peacefully with their neighbors (as a more indigenous people there), and they should be for many decades to come...

We can benefit them as well, since they're more likely to disenfranchised, if not in the same predicament as Palestinians...

Israel's actions have proved it must be dismantled. It is a rogue state. There's no coming back for it now.

my idea is draw a random shape on the map of europe and make all the "israelis" go there

Settlers can stay if they wish, they just wont be settlers anymore. Make it secular and ruthlessly remove all traces of apartheid. And just for fun make it a two-state solution. One state for Palestinians and another state also for Palestinians. Call it Palestine 2

Un ~~stalin~~council with un peacekeeping force rams through court reform, where all judgements about land and houses (including all refugees in all countries) go through un-appointed non-aligned judges panels, if person only wants compensation they get shuttled to the end of the court line. Then they shuffle people around the land. After living situation is resolved (after return of palestinians and rebuilding houses for israelis who want to stay), land becomes sold-able, and reparations are being paid via bond issuance. Un peacekeeping force is removed after two generations, if there are no further problems.

*all passed legislation is subject to icj review if local groups think its discriminatory outside of right-of-return framework

The situation in occupied and greater Palestine is complex and it's necessary to understand that there needs to be a levelling of the playing field; a vast amount of reparations from Israel is required.

The problem with a no-state solution is that in effect it amounts to kicking away the ladder. If Israel was abolished tomorrow Palestinians and former-Israelis would not be starting from the same position - Israel has built itself up while continuously knocking Palestine down. The disparities in health, education, economic participation, development, and the sheer degree of trauma that Palestinians have been subjected to and so on isn't going to be swept away with a no-state solution.

Thus I would argue that there needs to be a centralised authority which works to achieve restorative justice and to address the inequities that are now deeply embedded into the material conditions of Palestine.

It would be wonderful if we lived in immense abundance, where people would be overflowing with generosity, but people are parochial in their outlook by their very nature. It would be borderline impossible to get a hardline Zionist former-Israeli to wake up one morning and think "Yeah, I really would like to see 10% of what I produce to be diverted to the cultural enrichment of Palestinians!" For that matter, you don't take a person who gleefully slaughters Palestinian children one day and expect that they are going to be all kindness and compassion towards Palestinians the next simply because the state of Israel ceased to exist in the meantime. So there's going to be the need for a state of some description and I cannot imagine any other way of addressing the material conditions, let alone the structural and social and cultural factors that a liberated Palestine would have to grapple with.

I think that half of the population of Israel would return back to places like Europe and the US if Israel ceased to exist, especially when they are no longer provided the special privileges that the state of Israel currently affords them. I don't think that expelling former-Israelis is an ideal solution imo, although when Palestine is liberated I'm not going to condescend to dictate how they ought to go about their own liberation and decolonisation; if you sow the seed of colonialism but you don't like the fruit that this tree will eventually come bear, I'm not going to lose any sleep over it. Skill issue.

75 years of impunity created this problem. The situation calls for 75 years of whatever you call the opposite of impunity. Life sentences for asking dumb questions. A reign of terror which makes Robespierre look like a pacifist.

You hand over all Israeli territory to Palestinians. You try every Israeli politician, office holder, bureaucrat, soldier, cop, janitor, ceo, cfo, banker, etc. for crimes against humanity.

You get a leniency if you cooperate. You are barred from political, financial, or decision making office for 40 years. You are executed if you refuse to cooperate and are found guilty.

You abolish the entire educational curriculum. You abolish the military. You abolish Israeli cops. You execute every Israeli Prison Guard.

You put a lien on every Israeli real state holding where any and all profit is placed in trust to the Palestinian people.

the idea of not having a state is a very silly one. If the palestinians win tomorrow what do you think happens, do the fascist zionists all immediately leave? No! They will stay and fight, just like how the nazis continued to terrorise civilians in east germany. Equally the United states and its lackeys will continue to try and dismantle the reunified palestine, as joe biden says "if israel did not exist, we would create one". So what is a state, a state is the machinary through which one class subordinates another. Are there multiple opposing classes in palestine? Yes, at least two, indiginous palestinians and zionists (if you object to this definition of classes please refer to losurdos "class strugle"). If the palestinians do not form a state to subordinate the zionists (in some way) then, and this is the important part, the zionists will simply reform the state of israel. A no state solution where everyone heals sounds great, if you dont remember that one side needs to heal much more than the other, and the other is actively trying to kill every palestinian and will continue to do so as long as they exist, as is inherent in the setller class position.

I recommend this edited speech excerpt by parenti also https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nQUEUM0t1y8

A single state solution similar to post apartheid South Africa (but with much better economic reform, affirmative action and reparations towards Palestinians, etc) would probably be the most ideal solution in my opinion, but I think it's very unrealistic. An actual independent Palestinian state within a two state solution framework is probably the most realistic best outcome, and hopefully a stepping stone to better things in the future.

A two-state solution is no longer viable outside of the entire international community (the real international community led by China, Russia, and Iran, not the US and its vassals) forcefully imposing a two-state solution on the Palestinians and Zionists. There are only two options: a state of Israel where every single Palestinian has been either exterminated or expelled from their homeland or a state of Palestine where every single Zionist with means has fled to the West with the political elites forming a provisional government in Miami. The question becomes what happens to the Zionists without means. I don't think anyone has a real answer to this question since everything is in flux.

Not every Israeli is a Zionist. There are Hasidic communities within Israel that have protested and faced reprisal from the Zionist entity. There are also conscious objectors, few as they are, who are currently stuck in prison for refusing to join the IOF. These people have a place in a Republic of Palestine. But for all the other Zionist Israelis who not only refused to stand with the Resistance but taken up arms against it, the clock is ticking when the Palestinians, as noble and magnanimous against their wretched oppressors as they are, will finally run out of patience.

The Palestinians have thus far shown far more compassion and mercy to the Zionists than the Zionists deserve, going so far as to bake a birthday cake for one of the hostages. But after so much death and destruction, the Palestinians will eventually treat the Zionists the way the Zionists have treated the Palestinians, and the Zionists will have no one to blame but themselves.

I'm a pusher-backer against the "two-state solution is suddenly bad" thing