My grey matter refuses to process whatever is happening here. I will simply continue to not look at twitter.
Some binary and passing trans people get upset when they're in queer spaces and asked for their pronouns or referred to as "they/them" before someone knows their pronouns because in non queer spaces, people assume their gender based off appearance and gender them appropriately (because theyre binary and passing). These people think even in queer spaces you should assume peoples gender based off appearance because it makes them personally feel good to be gendered correctly without having to explain themselves
This doesn't go over well with non passing or non binary trans people for the obvious reasons
"Some of you might be misgendered, but that's a risk I'm willing to take"
Okay I'm not that offline, I am a non binary and a trans people.
I think I was happier when I did not understand that this Twitter® Screenshot™ is just binies getting up in arms over jack shit, again. Like hey, didn't Contrapoints do exactly this bit about feelin sad people use they/them and wanting to get presumptively gendered correctly? Twitter needs new material.
It disappointing but not surprising that some binary trans people are okay with transphobia if they benefit from it
Comprador shit
I envy your inner calm
Gotta love how the truscummy "I hate it when people ask for pronouns because people should just base your pronouns on how you look!" take conveniently neglects the existence of androgynous people.
Like I said, assimilationist pick me ass motherfuckers.
Ah an unstoppable force (pronoun circles) meets an immovable object (trans women getting clocked and subsequently degendered), producing a new kind of Twitter discourse where everyone is fundamentally incapable of understanding each other.
Like something that's not being brought up here is: it's easier to pass in cisciety than to be stealth in a queer meetup. So are the cis men and women in your LGBT group being they/them'd and asked their pronouns, or is that being subconsciously reserved for the transgender men and women who get clocked? I think both sides of this debate are assuming different fundamentals here.
People think I'm a cishet ally too much it drives me nuts. Why are my vibes so fucked
But I've also had the situation where the cissies pronoun circle so the removed (me) would spill the beans
and then they want brownie points for being allies. Either do these intro things consistently or have the courtesy to tremble before a trans person when you ask them
or is that being subconsciously reserved for the transgender men and women who get clocked
this is my overwhelming experience with any group that doesnt have trans leadership. It reached the point where some cis woman turned to me and my partner, looked at us for half a second and said "we should do introductions, with pronouns". Mind you, I had shaken hands with everybody about two hours ago.
The consequence from this obv isnt that passology is good, lol. This whole thing sounds super heated to me and people seem to extrapolate the other side having the worst possible assumptions and beliefs from every statement to score cheap dunks and feel good.
This is exactly it. Like, I have a good friend who gets gendered correctly pretty regularly in cishet spaces but just gets misgendered/degendered constantly in queer spaces. It's getting harder for me to get her to hang out with my in queer spaces as a result. Her presentation is not queer
some of the replies to that quoted tweet are amazing, "just pass harder, idiot" damn, thank you for the pro-tip ma'am, i haven't considered that
How exactly do I "pass" as nonbinary?
According to many of the replies, we do, in fact, owe everyone androgyny
brb, building an orbital strike cannon that fires copies of Julia Serano's Whipping Girl at people who post bad-faith pronoun discourse
Skill issue, just be so well known your pronouns precede you
Alternatively, hire a guy to belt out your pronouns like hes reading royal titles
Honestly I'm drunk as hell right now (on company time). We have cool little stickers at our lgbt center
This is cool and good.
This all started because Catboy removedry said that using "they/them" if you are unsure is perfectly reasonable and not necessarily transphobic.
We all know some people use it in a cynical way but the thing that kicked off this whole discourse was just about how to address people who you don't know their preferred pronouns and it might not be safe or acceptable to just outright ask.
Edit: lol got by the slur filter oops.
Hot take, the slur filter doesn't understand context, and as a result, clamps down on various kinds of queer slang. And I think that's cringe.
Like, look at this section from My Gender Workbook by Kate Bornstien, where trans people are describing their experience of gender:
These are beautiful, amazing, and I absolutely adore every single one!
But the Hexbear slur filter would butcher these so bad, they'd read like a Papa Roach radio edit
Suffocation. No breathing. Don't give a removed if I removed
I'd prefer to be "they'd" over being asked, but in queer spaces, I'm okay with it.
The default "they" is just easiest for everyone involved. Its not reasonable to exchange pronouns in every single minor interaction with everybody.
on twitter
Just ask for pronouns lmao
Or their name? Pretty easy not to misgender someone if you just use their name.
What if they have a gender neutral name, or a name in a language not yours, this is still assuming the gender based on the name
No just use name instead of pronoun
So "she's the worst" becomes "Gary's the worst"
That's gonna make certain conversations in the English language unwieldily as fuck
These people need to interact with a real person in real life. It is not healthy to spend any amount of time on twitter crying about pronouns. That's what conservatives do.
People who discriminate against non-passing trans people fucking suck (I think they're called truscum?)
I think truscum are more anti-nonbinary and don't recognize you as trans unless you fully transition and do all your power to assimilate into one of the 2 genders, but I haven't been in truscum spaces for a few years now
Truscum is usually hostile against nonbinary people, usually pathologizes transness (dysphoria as a proof of validity), is usually highly assimilationist and usually favors some form of medical and legal gatekeeping, but some of these may be softened up depending on the truscum in question.
Requirements to "fully" transition, to be straight or to buy into the claim that you actually are or at least used to be your AGAB are rarer nowadays, but they're still around.
Wait is 'folks' not acceptable or is this commenter being hyperbolic? This has been in my vocabulary for my whole life.
There used to be (might still be?) a "folx" contingent but I think most people have concluded (correctly in my book) that "folks" is perfectly gender neutral as is
Theyre being hyperbolic, you're fine
I don't think it's transphobic to they/them everyone until you know what their gender is but I totally get wanting people to assume my gender correctly. I want that pretty bad honestly. But like I don't pass at all so If everyone did this they would probably misgender me constantly
Honest question; Is all this concern and 'worry' about misgendering kind of the problem? I don't want to misgender but in a random meeting with some one i just met if I accidentally misgender and am corrected I'll apologize and not do it again. (Also working on just dropping gendered terms)
I feel like ppl are trying to make it seem like crazy hard to do.
I've accidently dead named friends that I meet before transitioning. I apologize.
Am I the asshole?
I don't think you're an asshole or even did anything wrong, but yes it does hurt some people. Really depends on person to person but like, when you get misgendered it means you're being perceived as the wrong gender. When everyone does this every day it absolutely grinds me down and just saps all hope from me.
Like, I have to go basically sit in my room and be like, will there ever be a time when I'm not just perceived as some man in a dress or something? It does hurt. And I don't want people gendering me correctly to be some laborious process for them. I don't want people to have to try. I know it's not realistic
But also I definitely understand that it's not the fault of the people perceiving me, it's just reality.
I don't want to misgender but in a random meeting with some one i just met if I accidentally misgender and am corrected I'll apologize and not do it again. (Also working on just dropping gendered terms)
Nah you're good.
Sentiment matters. It only matters when someone intended it, or when someone is clearly not trying and has made the mistake many times even after being told. The latter gets a bit murky and comes down to effort.
Im trans. I have habitually called everyone "they" since I was like 5. Most people cis and trans alike, don't really seem to care. People who do will tell me, and I make a mental note that I shouldn't call that person they.
It's that easy.
Why does comrade, the most powerful pronoun, not simply eat the other pronouns?
traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns
Welcome to /c/traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns, an anti-capitalist meme community for transgender and gender diverse people.
-
Please follow the Hexbear Code of Conduct
-
Selfies are not permitted for the personal safety of users.
-
No personal identifying information may be posted or commented.
-
Stay on topic (trans/gender stuff).
-
Bring a trans friend!
-
Any image post that gets 200 upvotes with "banner" or "rule 6" in the title becomes the new banner.
-
Posts about dysphoria/trauma/transphobia should be NSFW tagged for community health purposes.
-
When made outside of NSFW tagged posts, comments about dysphoria/traumatic/transphobic material should be spoiler tagged.
-
Arguing in favor of transmedicalism is unacceptable. This is an inclusive and intersectional community.
-
While this is mostly a meme community, we allow most trans related posts as we grow the trans community on the fediverse.
If you need your neopronouns added to the list, please contact the site admins.
Remember to report rulebreaking posts, don't assume someone else has already done it!
Matrix Group Chat:
Suggested Matrix Client: Cinny
https://matrix.to/#/#tracha:chapo.chat
WEBRINGS:
🏳️⚧️ Transmasculine Pride Ring 🏳️⚧️
⬅️ Left 🏳️⚧️🏳️🌈 Be Crime Do Gay Webring 🏳️⚧️🏳️🌈 Right ➡️